| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
* I think looking at online solutions is cheating. Anybody caught doing it should be punished. --[[User:Alibaba|Alibaba]] 16:12, 2 March 2009 (UTC) | * I think looking at online solutions is cheating. Anybody caught doing it should be punished. --[[User:Alibaba|Alibaba]] 16:12, 2 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
| + | |||
| + | * Mmmmm… I think is a little bit insensitive to say that looking to solutions online is cheating. First, the objective of homework is to motivate students to familiarize with the course concepts, and develop a set of desired skills. Taking a look to a solution is part of that learning process. The unethical behavior shows up when the student does not study and/or does not try to first solve the problems without a solution. If the student works very hard on the homework without looking to a solution, then the objective of the teacher was accomplished—the professor made the student to study, think, and learn. Consequently, there is no problem with the student searching for extra help. Moreover, finding a solution (after trying the problem by him/herself) may help the student to learn where is his/her mistake. --[[User:Hsantosv|Hsantosv]] 16:34, 2 March 2009 (UTC) | ||
*Write an opinion here. --sign your name | *Write an opinion here. --sign your name | ||
Revision as of 12:35, 2 March 2009
Let's discuss the availability of hw solutions online.
We all know that many homework solutions are available online. With current search technology, it is easier than ever to find a specific solution one is looking for. Does looking at these solutions hinder learning? Is it ethical to look at them? What is the best way for a professor to deal with the availability of homework solutions online?
Let's discuss this "forum style" below.
- Something interesting happened on the ECE301 page (Spring 2009) the other day: somebody revealed that there is an online version of the solution manual and gave the link for it. I personally have known about the existence of this online solution manual for a long time, so in the past I have always taken that into account when assigning homework in ECE301. But I suspect many professors are unaware that the answers to the homework questions they give can be found online. It would be nice to hear what students have to say about that. Mboutin 15:53, 2 March 2009 (UTC)
- I think looking at online solutions is cheating. Anybody caught doing it should be punished. --Alibaba 16:12, 2 March 2009 (UTC)
- Mmmmm… I think is a little bit insensitive to say that looking to solutions online is cheating. First, the objective of homework is to motivate students to familiarize with the course concepts, and develop a set of desired skills. Taking a look to a solution is part of that learning process. The unethical behavior shows up when the student does not study and/or does not try to first solve the problems without a solution. If the student works very hard on the homework without looking to a solution, then the objective of the teacher was accomplished—the professor made the student to study, think, and learn. Consequently, there is no problem with the student searching for extra help. Moreover, finding a solution (after trying the problem by him/herself) may help the student to learn where is his/her mistake. --Hsantosv 16:34, 2 March 2009 (UTC)
- Write an opinion here. --sign your name
- Write an answer here. --sign your name
- Write an answer to this answer here. --sign your name
- Write another answer here. --sign your name
- Write an answer here. --sign your name
- Write an opinion here. --sign your name
- Write an answer here. --sign your name
- Write an answer to this answer here. --sign your name
- Write another answer here. --sign your name
- Write an answer here. --sign your name
