Line 27: Line 27:
 
----
 
----
  
*Review by Yerkebulan Y.  
+
*Review by Yerkebulan Y.
  
&nbsp;You provided good and clear explanation of rep and comb both graphically and by equations. You should have also explained impulse train p<sub>T</sub>(t) graphically. And at the end you just mentioned that comb is a CTFT&nbsp;of a rep. I think it would be better if you also included that rep is CTFT&nbsp;of a comb.Anyway, good job&nbsp;!<br>  
+
&nbsp;You provided good and clear explanation of rep and comb both graphically and by equations. You should have also explained impulse train p<sub>T</sub>(t) graphically. And at the end you just mentioned that comb is a CTFT&nbsp;of a rep. I think it would be better if you also included that rep is CTFT&nbsp;of a comb.Anyway, good job&nbsp;! I understood a lot from your lecture. )<br>  
  
 
----
 
----
Line 35: Line 35:
 
*Review by Soonho Kwon
 
*Review by Soonho Kwon
  
&nbsp;The outline is very helpful to understand this topic, especially when I wanted to make sure I was following this slecture. The graphical explanation was done perfectly and the mathematical expressions were good as well.
+
&nbsp;The outline is very helpful to understand this topic, especially when I wanted to make sure I was following this slecture. The graphical explanation was done perfectly and the mathematical expressions were good as well.  
  
 
----
 
----
Line 41: Line 41:
 
*Review by Fabian Faes
 
*Review by Fabian Faes
  
I really enjoyed the use of graphics to illustrate what a rep and a comb function look like. It really aids the understanding a lot! The flow seems very natural to me and I think it has a very good structure and explains the mathematics in terms that are easy to understand and follow. My favourite feature of this Slecture would have to be the link in the references to the list of YouTube videos where one can get more information if desired. Great Job!
+
I really enjoyed the use of graphics to illustrate what a rep and a comb function look like. It really aids the understanding a lot! The flow seems very natural to me and I think it has a very good structure and explains the mathematics in terms that are easy to understand and follow. My favourite feature of this Slecture would have to be the link in the references to the list of YouTube videos where one can get more information if desired. Great Job!  
  
 
----
 
----
Line 47: Line 47:
 
*Review by Talha Takleh Omar Takleh
 
*Review by Talha Takleh Omar Takleh
  
A very clean slecture, which is very good because it makes it easier for me to follow and understand. I like how you structured your slecture from basic information to detailed information about the topic. Short, concise and understandable points which helps me understand. Overall, great slecture.
+
A very clean slecture, which is very good because it makes it easier for me to follow and understand. I like how you structured your slecture from basic information to detailed information about the topic. Short, concise and understandable points which helps me understand. Overall, great slecture.  
  
 
----
 
----
Line 53: Line 53:
 
*Review by Student 7
 
*Review by Student 7
  
Authors answer here
+
Authors answer here  
  
 
----
 
----
Line 59: Line 59:
 
*Review by Student 8
 
*Review by Student 8
  
Authors answer here
+
Authors answer here  
  
 
----
 
----

Revision as of 14:24, 14 October 2014


Questions and Comments for Definition of Rep and Comb

A slecture by ECE student Xiaozhe Fan



Please post your reviews, comments, and questions below.



  • Miguel Castellanos

I like how you introduce both operators with a graphical representation and then proceed to give a mathematical description. This organization seems natural to me. I also like how you explain the use of each operator. In your introduction to the rep operator, I believe it should be $ k \in \mathbb{Z} $ since you want to allow k to be negative as well. Also, you could clean up your multiplications by removing the periods (multiplication is implied by convention). Great slecture!


  • Review by Jacob Holtman

The initial outline and the numbering system makes the process easy to see. In the comb example the graph is easy to understand. The function PT does not get explained until 1.1.4 while it is used in 1.1.3. It would be good to explain what that function means


  • Review by Yerkebulan Y.

 You provided good and clear explanation of rep and comb both graphically and by equations. You should have also explained impulse train pT(t) graphically. And at the end you just mentioned that comb is a CTFT of a rep. I think it would be better if you also included that rep is CTFT of a comb.Anyway, good job ! I understood a lot from your lecture. )


  • Review by Soonho Kwon

 The outline is very helpful to understand this topic, especially when I wanted to make sure I was following this slecture. The graphical explanation was done perfectly and the mathematical expressions were good as well.


  • Review by Fabian Faes

I really enjoyed the use of graphics to illustrate what a rep and a comb function look like. It really aids the understanding a lot! The flow seems very natural to me and I think it has a very good structure and explains the mathematics in terms that are easy to understand and follow. My favourite feature of this Slecture would have to be the link in the references to the list of YouTube videos where one can get more information if desired. Great Job!


  • Review by Talha Takleh Omar Takleh

A very clean slecture, which is very good because it makes it easier for me to follow and understand. I like how you structured your slecture from basic information to detailed information about the topic. Short, concise and understandable points which helps me understand. Overall, great slecture.


  • Review by Student 7

Authors answer here


  • Review by Student 8

Authors answer here


Back to ECE438, Fall 2014

Alumni Liaison

Followed her dream after having raised her family.

Ruth Enoch, PhD Mathematics