(New page: The peer review for Homework 3)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
The peer review for Homework 3
+
Because we are so close to the end of the semester, in lieu of a clustering assignment, the last homework will be the peer review of homework 2. Each student will be assigned another student's paper to review by e-mail.
 +
 
 +
= Description =
 +
 
 +
Double blind review.
 +
 
 +
What should the review contain?
 +
 
 +
*Constructive comments. Do this for each question
 +
*# Summarize what they did
 +
*# Say what is good 
 +
*# Say what could be improved   
 +
*Grading. Grade the whole assignment.     
 +
*# OK (B)
 +
*# Good (A)
 +
*# Excellent/Very Good (A+)
 +
*# OK- or NOT OK (B-/Fail)   
 +
 
 +
Due April 25 11:59:59 pm (will accept it until April 28 if you handed
 +
in homework 2 on time.)

Revision as of 22:32, 17 April 2008

Because we are so close to the end of the semester, in lieu of a clustering assignment, the last homework will be the peer review of homework 2. Each student will be assigned another student's paper to review by e-mail.

Description

Double blind review.

What should the review contain?

  • Constructive comments. Do this for each question
    1. Summarize what they did
    2. Say what is good
    3. Say what could be improved
  • Grading. Grade the whole assignment.
    1. OK (B)
    2. Good (A)
    3. Excellent/Very Good (A+)
    4. OK- or NOT OK (B-/Fail)

Due April 25 11:59:59 pm (will accept it until April 28 if you handed in homework 2 on time.)

Alumni Liaison

Questions/answers with a recent ECE grad

Ryne Rayburn